How to Stop Making Payments on a Car You Can’t Afford Anymore (Without Ruining Your Credit)

By Md Emran Khan | July 13, 2025

You bought a car you loved — but now the payments are crushing you. Whether it’s due to a job loss, rising bills, or simply an overambitious purchase, you’re not alone. The good news is: you do have options before things spiral into repossession.

Let’s talk about how to get out of your auto loan legally and smartly — without wrecking your credit.

---

 First, What Happens If You Just Stop Paying?

If you simply stop paying:

• Your credit score could drop 100+ points
• Your car could be repossessed (often without warning)
• You may still owe the deficiency balance (what’s left after the car is sold at auction)
• You could be sued for the balance + late fees and collection costs

Bottom line: Avoid ghosting your lender. It creates more problems than it solves.

---

 Smarter Options If You Can’t Afford Your Car Anymore

1. Talk to Your Lender Immediately

Most lenders offer hardship programs. They may:

• Defer payments temporarily
• Modify the loan terms to lower payments
• Help you refinance

Pro Tip: Call before you miss a payment. Lenders are more flexible when you’re proactive.

---

2. Refinance for a Lower Payment

If your credit is decent, refinance into:

• A longer loan term
• A lower interest rate
• A co-signed loan with a family member

This can lower your monthly cost without damaging your credit.

---

3. Sell the Car and Pay Off the Loan

You can sell the car privately or to a dealership:

• Use the sale proceeds to pay off the loan
• If the car is worth less than the loan, cover the difference or use a personal loan

Example:
If you owe $24,000 but the car’s market value is $20,000, you’d need to pay $4,000 to settle.

---

4. Voluntary Repossession (Last Resort)

If all else fails, you can surrender the car to the lender:

• It hurts your credit, but less than an involuntary repo
• You still owe the balance after the car is sold
• Make sure to get everything in writing

Warning: This stays on your credit report for up to 7 years

---

5. Trade Down to a Cheaper Vehicle

Some dealers may let you trade your car for a lower-cost model. If the trade-in value is close to your loan balance, this can work.

---

6. Lease Transfer or Loan Assumption

If your car is leased or financed through certain lenders, you may be able to transfer the lease or loan to someone else (with lender approval).

Try platforms like:

• Swapalease
• LeaseTrader

---

 

What If You’re Behind Already?

• Don’t ignore letters or calls from your lender
• Ask if you qualify for hardship assistance
• Keep making partial payments if possible — it shows good faith
• Avoid title loan companies — they often worsen the situation

---

 Real Story

“I was paying $540/month for a car I couldn’t afford after I got laid off. Instead of defaulting, I sold the car and took a $3,000 personal loan to cover the rest. It saved my credit.” — Emran

---

 FAQ: Ending a Car Loan You Can’t Afford

Q: Can I give the car back without hurting my credit?
A: Not without some credit impact, but voluntary repossession is slightly better than forced.

Q: What happens if I sell the car but still owe money?
A: You must pay the difference between the loan balance and sale price.

Q: Can I trade in a car I owe more on?
A: Yes, but the remaining balance gets rolled into the new loan, which can be risky.

---

 Source Comparison Table: Solutions for Unaffordable Car Payments

Source	Type	Summary	Link
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB)	Government Resource	Offers legal guidance on car loan rights and repossession.	Visit
NerdWallet – What to Do If You Can’t Afford Your Car	Financial Guide	Explains options like trade-ins, sales, and refinance.	Read
Experian – Voluntary Repossession Guide	Credit Bureau	Pros and cons of surrendering your car voluntarily.	Learn
Bankrate – Car Loan Refinance Tips	Finance Tool	How refinancing can reduce payments and avoid default.	Explore
DaveRamsey.com – Car Debt Advice	Personal Finance Blog	Dave’s no-nonsense approach to getting out of a bad loan.	View

---

 

Read More Articles